Understanding the cascade of GCM and downscaling uncertainties in hydro-climatic projections over India

Tarul Sharma, H. Vittal, Surbhi Chhabra, Kaustubh Salvi, Subimal Ghosh, Subhankar Karmakar

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

India is a major agrarian country strongly impacted by spatio-temporal variations in the Indian monsoon. The impact assessment is usually accomplished by implementing projections from general circulation models (GCMs). Unfortunately, these projections cannot capture the dynamicity of the monsoon and require either statistical (SD) or dynamical (DD) downscaling of the GCM projections to a finer resolution. Both downscaling techniques can capture the spatio-temporal variation in climatic variables but are marred by uncertainty in the projections resulting from the choice of the GCM and downscaling method, which affects climate change adaptations. Here, we assessed uncertainties in the projections of hydro-climatic variables over India by considering multiple downscaling techniques, multiple GCMs, and their combined effects (referred as the total uncertainty). Multiple hydrological variables were simulated by implementing the variable infiltration capacity model that considered outputs from DD (derived by the coordinated regional climate downscaling experiment, CORDEX) and SD forced with multiple GCM simulations. Our results showed that the SD projections captured the observed spatio-temporal variability of hydro-climatic variables more efficiently than the DD projections. Importantly, contribution from the downscaled projections to the total uncertainty was significantly smaller compared to the inter-GCM uncertainty. We believe uncertainty analysis is an important component of good scientific practice; however, several researchers appear to be rather reluctant to embrace the concept of uncertainty in making projections, predictions, and forecasting. It remains a common practice to show climate change exercises to decision-makers/stakeholders, without uncertainty bounds. Here, a successful attempt was made to identify the key sources of uncertainty and adequately bracket the uncertainty, indicating a requirement of the code of practice to provide formal guidance, particularly for climate-change impact assessments. This consequently emphasized the importance of follow-up research to understand the inter-GCM uncertainty, which has a significant impact on sustainable agriculture and water resources management in India.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)e178-e190
JournalInternational Journal of Climatology
Volume38
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01-04-2018
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

downscaling
general circulation model
monsoon
temporal variation
climate change
alternative agriculture
uncertainty analysis
regional climate
stakeholder
infiltration
prediction
simulation
experiment

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Atmospheric Science

Cite this

Sharma, Tarul ; Vittal, H. ; Chhabra, Surbhi ; Salvi, Kaustubh ; Ghosh, Subimal ; Karmakar, Subhankar. / Understanding the cascade of GCM and downscaling uncertainties in hydro-climatic projections over India. In: International Journal of Climatology. 2018 ; Vol. 38. pp. e178-e190.
@article{37162ab9d6b34185ae27b28033c62ab0,
title = "Understanding the cascade of GCM and downscaling uncertainties in hydro-climatic projections over India",
abstract = "India is a major agrarian country strongly impacted by spatio-temporal variations in the Indian monsoon. The impact assessment is usually accomplished by implementing projections from general circulation models (GCMs). Unfortunately, these projections cannot capture the dynamicity of the monsoon and require either statistical (SD) or dynamical (DD) downscaling of the GCM projections to a finer resolution. Both downscaling techniques can capture the spatio-temporal variation in climatic variables but are marred by uncertainty in the projections resulting from the choice of the GCM and downscaling method, which affects climate change adaptations. Here, we assessed uncertainties in the projections of hydro-climatic variables over India by considering multiple downscaling techniques, multiple GCMs, and their combined effects (referred as the total uncertainty). Multiple hydrological variables were simulated by implementing the variable infiltration capacity model that considered outputs from DD (derived by the coordinated regional climate downscaling experiment, CORDEX) and SD forced with multiple GCM simulations. Our results showed that the SD projections captured the observed spatio-temporal variability of hydro-climatic variables more efficiently than the DD projections. Importantly, contribution from the downscaled projections to the total uncertainty was significantly smaller compared to the inter-GCM uncertainty. We believe uncertainty analysis is an important component of good scientific practice; however, several researchers appear to be rather reluctant to embrace the concept of uncertainty in making projections, predictions, and forecasting. It remains a common practice to show climate change exercises to decision-makers/stakeholders, without uncertainty bounds. Here, a successful attempt was made to identify the key sources of uncertainty and adequately bracket the uncertainty, indicating a requirement of the code of practice to provide formal guidance, particularly for climate-change impact assessments. This consequently emphasized the importance of follow-up research to understand the inter-GCM uncertainty, which has a significant impact on sustainable agriculture and water resources management in India.",
author = "Tarul Sharma and H. Vittal and Surbhi Chhabra and Kaustubh Salvi and Subimal Ghosh and Subhankar Karmakar",
year = "2018",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/joc.5361",
language = "English",
volume = "38",
pages = "e178--e190",
journal = "International Journal of Climatology",
issn = "0899-8418",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",

}

Understanding the cascade of GCM and downscaling uncertainties in hydro-climatic projections over India. / Sharma, Tarul; Vittal, H.; Chhabra, Surbhi; Salvi, Kaustubh; Ghosh, Subimal; Karmakar, Subhankar.

In: International Journal of Climatology, Vol. 38, 01.04.2018, p. e178-e190.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Understanding the cascade of GCM and downscaling uncertainties in hydro-climatic projections over India

AU - Sharma, Tarul

AU - Vittal, H.

AU - Chhabra, Surbhi

AU - Salvi, Kaustubh

AU - Ghosh, Subimal

AU - Karmakar, Subhankar

PY - 2018/4/1

Y1 - 2018/4/1

N2 - India is a major agrarian country strongly impacted by spatio-temporal variations in the Indian monsoon. The impact assessment is usually accomplished by implementing projections from general circulation models (GCMs). Unfortunately, these projections cannot capture the dynamicity of the monsoon and require either statistical (SD) or dynamical (DD) downscaling of the GCM projections to a finer resolution. Both downscaling techniques can capture the spatio-temporal variation in climatic variables but are marred by uncertainty in the projections resulting from the choice of the GCM and downscaling method, which affects climate change adaptations. Here, we assessed uncertainties in the projections of hydro-climatic variables over India by considering multiple downscaling techniques, multiple GCMs, and their combined effects (referred as the total uncertainty). Multiple hydrological variables were simulated by implementing the variable infiltration capacity model that considered outputs from DD (derived by the coordinated regional climate downscaling experiment, CORDEX) and SD forced with multiple GCM simulations. Our results showed that the SD projections captured the observed spatio-temporal variability of hydro-climatic variables more efficiently than the DD projections. Importantly, contribution from the downscaled projections to the total uncertainty was significantly smaller compared to the inter-GCM uncertainty. We believe uncertainty analysis is an important component of good scientific practice; however, several researchers appear to be rather reluctant to embrace the concept of uncertainty in making projections, predictions, and forecasting. It remains a common practice to show climate change exercises to decision-makers/stakeholders, without uncertainty bounds. Here, a successful attempt was made to identify the key sources of uncertainty and adequately bracket the uncertainty, indicating a requirement of the code of practice to provide formal guidance, particularly for climate-change impact assessments. This consequently emphasized the importance of follow-up research to understand the inter-GCM uncertainty, which has a significant impact on sustainable agriculture and water resources management in India.

AB - India is a major agrarian country strongly impacted by spatio-temporal variations in the Indian monsoon. The impact assessment is usually accomplished by implementing projections from general circulation models (GCMs). Unfortunately, these projections cannot capture the dynamicity of the monsoon and require either statistical (SD) or dynamical (DD) downscaling of the GCM projections to a finer resolution. Both downscaling techniques can capture the spatio-temporal variation in climatic variables but are marred by uncertainty in the projections resulting from the choice of the GCM and downscaling method, which affects climate change adaptations. Here, we assessed uncertainties in the projections of hydro-climatic variables over India by considering multiple downscaling techniques, multiple GCMs, and their combined effects (referred as the total uncertainty). Multiple hydrological variables were simulated by implementing the variable infiltration capacity model that considered outputs from DD (derived by the coordinated regional climate downscaling experiment, CORDEX) and SD forced with multiple GCM simulations. Our results showed that the SD projections captured the observed spatio-temporal variability of hydro-climatic variables more efficiently than the DD projections. Importantly, contribution from the downscaled projections to the total uncertainty was significantly smaller compared to the inter-GCM uncertainty. We believe uncertainty analysis is an important component of good scientific practice; however, several researchers appear to be rather reluctant to embrace the concept of uncertainty in making projections, predictions, and forecasting. It remains a common practice to show climate change exercises to decision-makers/stakeholders, without uncertainty bounds. Here, a successful attempt was made to identify the key sources of uncertainty and adequately bracket the uncertainty, indicating a requirement of the code of practice to provide formal guidance, particularly for climate-change impact assessments. This consequently emphasized the importance of follow-up research to understand the inter-GCM uncertainty, which has a significant impact on sustainable agriculture and water resources management in India.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85045911527&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85045911527&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/joc.5361

DO - 10.1002/joc.5361

M3 - Article

VL - 38

SP - e178-e190

JO - International Journal of Climatology

JF - International Journal of Climatology

SN - 0899-8418

ER -